09/12/07

Mindblowing wine list and the best servers in town

by andypboy

Wow - I knew this was Chicago's oldest wine bar, but didn't know it was, by far, the city's best. I don't think any other wine bar in town has even HALF the number of wines Webster's does, and their prices are cheaper than anyone elses, too. Best of all, the servers are friendly and they know their stuff! Yes, the atmosphere is great, the food is delicious, and the service is top notch, but it's more than that - these guys really know their wines and are passionate while unpretentious. The owners even take their waitstaff to Europe every year to visit wineries and taste!! I mean really, who else in the entire country even does that???

There's no point in going into details on the wines - they have 40 by the glass that constantly change, they are consistently tasty, the prices are great, and you never see generic wines on the list (my big beef). They also have a great beer list (about 20 bottles) and a quality spirits list. The food is fantastic - not the largest menu, but everything is tight and goes perfectly with wine. For light bites, you can't beat their tapas selections (which include Italian and French traditional "bites" too), and their entrees are all classic regional dishes intended to pair with wines from the same region. And the food is inexpensive, too.

Bottom line: no other wine bar in this city really has taken it to the level Webster's has. If you haven't been to Webster's, you are missing the boat!

• Pros: Quality throughout in a chill setting
• Cons: None

11/15/06

Great low key wine bar

by marge715

Dark, romantic atmosphere. Try and snag a couch. A big wine list with great wine flights for sampling. The servers are really helpful and knowledgable about the menu.

• Pros: Big wine selection, helpful staff

09/15/06

Casual Euro-style bar, poor service and incorrectly stored products.

by burgundyboi

I enjoyed the atmosphere--fairly quiet, small wooden tables and chairs with an assorment of art. However, I was very disappointed in the service and how my party was treated. We had a diverse crowd with serveral wine-savy people in the group. We ordered among other bottles, a white Bordeaux, which was fizzy and nearly room temperature. No taste of the bottle was presented to the selector and everyone agreed that perhaps the wine had been subjected to extreme heat at some point during shipping or storage. We kindly asked if we would arrange for a different bottle or to have that one discounted so we could purchase another bottle; our waiter denied all attempts in a very terse manner. I work in customer service and collect wine--I believe it should be a relaxed, enjoyable experience without any snobbiness or stress.

Needless to say, my night was not enjoyable, save my company, they were all very well behaved.

I have no want to return to this establishment with so many other wonderful options here in Chicago.

• Pros: The space and decor
• Cons: Terrible service and unpredictable wine quality (which is not allowed to be returned.)