I walked in on Saturday at around 4:30pm and ordered a slice of cheese pizza. I have had it before and it was good, but this time the slice looked like a catchers mitt. It was absolutely disgusting.
They had three guys working there, but when I used the bathroom there was no soap in there, could not get a drop. How do these guys wash their hands for the food. The guy that served me the pizza looked worse than the pizza.
disgusting- stay away!.
I walked into Santullo's and tried to order a slice of their Thursday "special margarita pizza." The manager told me he was counting the money in the register and I'd have to wait, and he was completely rude about it. Then I stood there for about 3 mins and asked if he could just put the order in and start warming the pizza because my dogs were waiting in the car (it's supposed to be a quick joint for slices!), and he said no! I stood there a few more mins and finally he told the other employee to put the pizza in. It cost almost $5 for a slice of pizza, so I expected it to be good. It was disgusting! It must have been hours old! It tasted like cardboard, there was hardly any cheese, and the sauce tasted like Ragu. I will never go back there again!
Late-night Wicker Park spot for subs and slices.. In Short A family-friendly sandwich shop by day, this comfortable neighborhood spot becomes a late-late-night haunt on weekends, when Bud drafts and tasty slices of thin-crust New York pizza are too tempting to pass up. Also on the menu: baked chicken Vesuvio, roast beef and meatball subs, soups, salads and homemade sides like pasta salad, garlic bread and mac and cheese. The handsome space is plenty inviting too, with red vinyl booths, wooden chairs and big picture windows that look out onto North Avenue.